Farmworkers working in a field on a sunny day
The 10-member Agricultural Advisory Committee was formed in October to provide direction to the Santa Clara County Department of Planning and Development on its redo of a proposed agricultural zoning change. File photo.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

After a massive backlash from farmers, winery owners and equestrians, Santa Clara County officials hit the reset button on a proposed rural zoning amendment, bringing in an agriculture advisory group to make it right.

At the request of District 1 Supervisor Sylvia Arenas and the county Housing, Land Use, Environment and Transportation Committee, the Agricultural Advisory Committee was formed in October to advise on a new rural zoning amendment draft, after the bungled version in September 2025. The advisory committee is tasked with helping the county come up with a more clear and consistent plan aligned with the Santa Clara Valley Agricultural Plan and the county’s general plan.

The 10-person committee has met three times, — Oct. 8, Oct. 22 and most recently on Nov. 10 — to advise the county Department of Planning and Development based on its recent public outreach. All meetings are open to the public, with additional public outreach planned. And while the committee is providing feedback directly to the planning department, residents can email public comments to aid the development of the new draft plan.

Kim Engelhardt, an advisory committee member and Lion Ranch Vineyards proprietor, said the planning department is going to heed the committee’s advice and return for its final scheduled meeting in February with concepts to aid in formulating the zoning amendment — though no timeframe for the final draft has been established.

“We as a committee are a sounding board for county planning to understand unintended consequences of any code they write,” Engelhardt told San José Spotlight. “The old draft had some pretty dire financial consequences (affecting the agriculture industry). We need to talk about this early to see if it works for farmers and other people in agriculture. I think we’re in for a long haul.”

Arenas said hundreds of farmers, winery owners, equestrians and residents made their voices heard last year after the initial draft release, sharing their concerns about the proposal.

“That’s why I led the Board of Supervisors to direct that planning reboot, both the policies proposed, which have been withdrawn, and also the community process,” Arenas told San José Spotlight. “We are currently deeply engaged in the tough work of that reboot. This hard work must lead to changes that make life better for agricultural businesses, while opening up new paths for our community to support our farmers.”

The other nine members of the committee include Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority agricultural specialist Anna Regalado, Frantoio Grove owner Jeff Martin, Gilroy Mayor Greg Bozzo, Terra Amico founder Joe Raineri, P&V Winery owner Paul Kermoyan, Santa Clara County Horseman’s Association board member Rachael Parakh, Santa Clara County Housing Authority Director of Housing Rebecca Garcia, Lone Oak Equestrian Center owner Stephen McHenry and Bill James, who is a member of the Cattlemen’s Association, Santa Clara County Farm Bureau and Loma Prieta Resource Conservation District.

Patrick McGarrity, a spokesperson for Arenas’ office, said the issue with the code is that it is updated infrequently, and when it is, it would be a partial change focusing on one of four different zone districts — exclusive agriculture, agricultural ranchlands, hillside and rural residential.

“It meant the zoning codes were patched together over different generations,” McGarrity told San José Spotlight, adding that over time there became issues in unincorporated areas regarding the term “local serving” that led to litigation and appeals. “So this (new draft) is trying to be implemented treating people fairly and in line with the general plan to preserve agriculture. The goal is not just to update it, but hit the nail on the head to make it easier to operate.”

In-line Donation CTA 2026_NewsMatch, V1 (950 x 287 px)

The draft redo has three tangible tasks: replace the “local serving” provisions with objective standards; simplify and standardize agricultural uses consistent with the Santa Clara Valley agricultural plan and county general plan land use policies; and limit uses in the exclusive agriculture zone to support long-term ag viability.

“The other big thing the planning department is trying to prevent is incompatible development,” Raineri told San José Spotlight. “They don’t want commercial development to replace agriculture. They are trying to preserve farmland.”

Raineri said that following the release of the draft in September last year, he was among those pushing back on the plan, resulting in the county hitting the reset button. He said the original draft would have put small farms like his in a precarious financial position. Now Raineri said it’s not about dwelling on what went wrong with the first draft, but focusing instead on getting it right this time around.

“Small and medium sized farms are essential. They are stewards of the land, provide nutritious local products, diversify food supply, preserve our agriculture identity in Santa Clara Valley,” Raineri said. “Supporting farmland without supporting small is an incomplete preservation policy. We need to come up with amendments economically viable to be here. It’s really about keeping ag alive because it’s the future.”

Contact Giovanni Albanese Jr. at [email protected].

Comment Policy (updated 5/10/2023): Readers are required to log in through a social media or email platform to confirm authenticity. We reserve the right to delete comments or ban users who engage in personal attacks, hate speech, excess profanity or make verifiably false statements. Comments are moderated and approved by admin.

Leave a Reply

Secret Link