Despite struggling financially, a San Jose school district plans to construct a new school.
El Distrito escolar de Franklin-McKinley board on Nov. 10 voted 3-2 to accept a more than 7-acre parcel donated by owner MTA Hillsdale to build a school on Communications Hill, a mixed-use urban neighborhood. Board President Hong Ha Hoang and Vice President Steven Sanchez voted against it.
The trustees who embraced the project said a school has been part of the development plans from the beginning, while the trustees against the plan said the idea is no longer realistic given the district’s declining enrollment, the closure of three schools last year and an estimated $93 million price tag to build the school.
Hoang said the district’s circumstances have changed significantly since the school was first envisioned more than 30 years ago.
“I respect the Communications Hill community’s years of advocacy and understand the desire for a neighborhood school,” Hoang told San José Spotlight. “My responsibility as a trustee is to consider the needs of every student and every school in Franklin-McKinley. We have declining enrollment, financial challenges and existing campuses that need modernization and facilities improvements. Before committing significant resources to a new school, we need to clearly understand what opportunities we may be giving up to improve learning environments for students.”
The San Jose City Council approved development of the Plan específico de Communications Hill in 1992. It sits on about 500 acres and is part of its Envision San Jose 2040 General Plan due to its proximity to freeways, public transit and downtown San Jose. The plan is for 4,700 homes, 67,500 square feet of commercial space, more than 1.4 million square feet of industrial park use, a fire station, school and various upgrades to the property.
About 2,500 of the planned 4,700 homes have been built. Before issuing building permits, San Jose ensures developers pay required impact fees or fulfill their obligations through donating land or constructing facilities for school districts, Marika Krause, spokesperson for the San Jose Planning, Building and Code Enforcement Department, told San José Spotlight.
Franklin-McKinley School District will have to pay roughly $4.8 million to developer KB Homes South Bay to cover costs for grading, adding a clean-soil cap and relocating a PG&E transmission line. The land is worth $20 million after these improvements, Assistant Superintendent Jason Vann said. If the district cannot meet a stipulation from MTA Hillsdale to commit $80 million toward construction by 2028, the district will lose the land, Superintendent Juan Cruz told San José Spotlight.
The district is relying on existing and future bond measures to cover these costs.
Local voters have passed several bond measures to support the district in recent years. In June, voters passed Measure C, a $142 million school facilities bond to support essential upgrades and improvements across district schools. Medida W, a $192 parcel tax with a 3% annual increase, passed in 2024 to replace two sunsetting measures that would expire this year. The new monies will restore performing arts and music programs for students in kindergarten through sixth grade, expand tutoring and counseling for at-risk students and maintain small class sizes for students at 16 San Jose schools.
Trustee Rudy Rodriguez said he is determined to honor the promise he made long ago to build a Communications Hill school.
“The new school will be an asset to our district through the hiring of more teachers and staff, along with retaining our children to stay in (Franklin-McKinley School District),” Rodriguez told San José Spotlight. “We cannot allow a charter or private school to be built on Communications Hill. If this happens, we will lose enrollment and limit our opportunity to create more jobs for teachers and staff.”
Eliana Garcia van der Pool said when she and her husband moved to Communications Hill in 2021, a neighborhood school was one of the caveats that came with purchasing their home. It was also a selling point for her in-laws and sister-in-law’s family.
“We thought, ‘This is great. They could walk our daughter to school,’ and that was a huge win for us,” she told San José Spotlight. “We purchased our home there with the intent of having that school built there in the community.”
Kendra Johnson-Moore, a board member for the Franklin-McKinley Education Association, sided with the trustees who voted no.
“We have existing schools with leaky roofs, broken sidewalks and serious maintenance needs,” she said at the Nov. 10 board meeting. “How can you justify building a new school when we haven’t taken care of the schools and students we already have?”
Tuan-Anh Huynh, president of Franklin-McKinley Education Association, said it doesn’t make sense to build a new school.
“When the school was promised, our student enrollment was more than double what it is now,” he said at the meeting. “We agree that opening a new school will capture students that live in the Communications Hill area, but it will also likely lead to a reshuffling of students.”
Communications Hill resident Yuong Wu urged the district to build the long-awaited school.
“This isn’t just an inconvenience for working parents, it directly impacts our children who deserve the same access to a local, supportive school community as students in any other neighborhood,” she said at the meeting.
Comuníquese con Lorraine Gabbert a través de [email protected].



Deje un comentario
Debes iniciar sesión para publicar un comentario.